by colm_mcm » Thu Feb 25, 2010 10:57 pm
sounds like your head gasket is on the way out. it's possible that water is only entering one cylinder, sometimes gaskets just go in certain points. Had a head gasket break down between 2 cylinders on a Fiat i had, just caused a misfire - no water or oil loss or mixing.
The usual reason for a gasket going is overheating, but it's unusual that yours isn't completely gone - as in you're not getting water and oil mixing.
What kind of shape is your water pump in? check for leaks from there.
My theory: water not circulating quickly enough, overheating caused gasket trouble, 2 seperate problems to rectify (but I'm not a mechanic so...)